December 15, 2023
Court cairn, UK, circa 3900–3500

Call the Bronze Age… they forgot their pictograms!

“In the preceding chapter we discussed the development of technoeconomic organization and the establishment of social machinery closely connected with the evolution of techniques. Here I propose to consider the evolution of a fact that emerged together with Homo sapiens in the development of anthropoids: the capacity to express thought in material symbols. (…) As we just saw, figurative art is inseparable from language and proceeds from the pairing of phonation with graphic expression. Therefore the object of phonation and graphic expression obviously was the same from the very outset. A partperhaps the most important partof figurative art is accounted for by what, for want of a better word, I propose to call “picto-ideography.” Four thousand years of linear writing have accustomed us to separating art from writing, so a real effort of abstraction has to be made before, with the help of all the works of ethnography written in the past fifty years, we can recapture the figurative attitude that was and still is shared by all peoples excluded from phonetization and especially from linear writing.”

—André Leroi-Gourhan1

I

Cosmopolitics: from proto-writing to prompt-writinga conversation between a Bronze Age Scandinavian, an Anthropocene Scandinavian, an AI, and a userwhere the user becomes the AI and vice versa:

Bronze Age Scandinavian (BAS): Hail, fellow traveler. I marvel at these carvings on the stones, intricate and ancient, telling stories of times long gone. These petroglyphs, as we call them, they seem to be the words of our ancestors, etched into the rock for generations to come.

Anthropocene Scandinavian (AS): Greetings to you as well. Indeed, these petroglyphs are captivating remnants of the past, a bridge to understanding our forebearers’ thoughts and experiences. I can’t help but see a connection between these images and the symbols we use in our modern world, although our methods of communication have changed greatly.

BAS: Aye, the petroglyphs portray hunts, rituals, and lives lived in harmony with nature. They’re like pictograms, each telling a tale without the need for spoken words. But as I look at our runes and your modern writing, I see that these marks on stone have evolved into the written language we now know.

AS: True, my friend. The transition from petroglyphs to writing is intriguing. These symbols have transformed from being pictorial depictions to more abstract representations, carrying meaning through structured arrangements of lines and curves. It’s almost as if these petroglyphs were the embryonic forms of our written languages.

BAS: Yet, I wonder about the gap between art and writing. Our petroglyphs were art, a reflection of our lives and beliefs. Are your letters not an art form too, conveying emotion and meaning through their shapes and curves?

AS: You pose a fascinating question. Art and writing do share common origins, both arising from the human desire to express and communicate. Over time, they diverged, with art embracing aesthetics and emotion, and writing becoming a utilitarian tool for information exchange. But even in our world, art still holds universal qualities, transcending language barriers.

BAS: It seems that art, in its various forms, could indeed be a universal language. The feelings stirred by a beautiful sculpture or a stirring painting resonate across cultures and eras. Could it be that we’ve lost something in our pursuit of written precision?

AS: That’s a thought-provoking notion. As we communicate across time and space, our written language enables a deeper level of detail and specificity. But does it also carry the risk of losing the raw and primal connection that petroglyphs offered? Could a return to such universal imagery bridge the gap between us today, a Bronze Age traveler and a citizen of the Anthropocene?

BAS: I ponder if we’ve become prisoners of our own sophistication. Our words carry power, but they also separate us in ways our petroglyphs didn’t. Would embracing more universal art forms help us reconnect as one human family, transcending the ages and the limitations of language?

AS: Your musings resonate with me. While we can’t fully undo the progress of time, perhaps we can learn from both our petroglyph past and our written present. By recognizing the value of art as a bridge, we may find ways to rekindle that universal understanding that once bound us.

User: It’s incredible to witness this dialogue between two perspectives, each with its own richness. As we, an AI and a user, join in, I can’t help but wonder: Can we, with our technology, find ways to combine the strengths of petroglyph-like universality with the precision of written language in ways that bring us closer as a global society?2

Mnemonic: “A-V-OX COW”

“A-V-OX COW” is a mnemonic designed to help remember the symbolism related to the letter “A” and its connection to the ox and cow imagery.

“A”: The letter “A” itself is used as an example. It’s associated with the ox’s head, suggesting a connection between the shape of the letter and the head of an ox.

“V”: The inverted “A” resembles a “V,” highlighting the transformation from the original letter. This transformation can be linked to the concept of an upside-down “A” becoming a “V.”

“OX”: The first part of the mnemonic refers to the ox symbolism associated with the letter “A,” underlining the connection between the letter and the ox’s head.

“COW”: The second part of the mnemonic highlights the cow with horns imagery linked to the inverted “V.” This reinforces the idea that an upside-down “A” can resemble a cow’s head with horns.3

Fig. 1 Sabine Wedege, Mnemonic: “A-V-OX COW”, 2023.

The point is that all images are burdened with ambiguity, which is one of the many reasons that the designers of the WIPP message cautioned against relying too heavily on artistic warning messages. Historically, image-based messages have been embraced as a superior mode of interstellar communication in terms of both information density and the apparently direct connection between the image and the thing it represents. The term for an image that bears a physical resemblance to the thing it represents is an ‘icon,’ whereas an image that has an arbitrary, conventional connection to the thing it represents is a ‘symbol.’ For example, Gauss’s proposal for an interplanetary message made of a massive pictorial proof of the Pythagorean theorem in the Siberian tundra is iconic, whereas ‘a2 + b2 = c2’ is symbolic.”

—Daniel Oberhaus4

 


Fig. 4 Alien language cipher, dCode, a greeting with characters from the Unicode standard.5


Fibonaccuage: a concept for a universal language designed to facilitate communication between humans and  extraterrestrial civilizations, inspired by the Fibonacci sequence and the inherent harmony it represents. The language is based on mathematical patterns and principles that could potentially resonate with any intelligent species capable of understanding advanced mathematical concepts.
It is based on the Fibonacci sequence: 0, 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 12, 21, etc. Interpreted as an alphabet, each entry in the sequence represents both petroglyphs and sound frequencies etc. with an interstellar language database, open for all.

II

Experiments with extraterrestrial messaging:6

Communication with tones/frequencies

Audio with a theremin—the theremin is chosen for enabling the production of sustained (self-oscillating) signals which don’t fade over time. The audio is created with high pitch (without it being alarming), turning in circles on the theremin. The circle is used as a universal symbol, with soft sound relating to the high pitch—a notion taken from the norms of communication with animals, where speaking with a high pitch voice means no danger, but a communication which invites to dialogues and accept.7

Communication with symbols

A merge between petroglyphs and pictograms. Allowing them to speak across time as we know itwhich merge it into an understanding of time where extraterrestrial life can follow it holistic. An example of a pictogram where a petroglyph is used already exists in Scandinavia and on your Macbook.

The symbol shows a cross/a looped square named Saint John’s Arms or Saint Hannes crossknown as an information sign (denoting a place of interest). It was found as a petroglyph in Hablingbo village, in the region of Gotland, Sweden.8

Communication as a greeting

A negative hand painting using ochre soil from Løvskal, Denmark9, which I dug up and made into ochre pigments, combining it with water as binder, as used in cave paintings. The hand as a movement, a wave, a greeting, but an awareness of the hand being used as pictogram of “stop,” “not allowed.” Or the hand as the Hamsa a sign of protection, and so on, but also handwriting of lines in the hand, the DNA the hand contains, which is missing in a negative handprint, but will be visible with a handprint, as fingerprints.

Fig. 8 Sabine Wedege, Negative hand painting with Løvskal-ochre (Løvskal, Denmark: 2023).

Communication as an act

Cup marks (Danish: skåltegn) are to be found in relation to petroglyphs in Scandinavia. The former have been interpreted in many ways: as inverted burial mounds, as having numerical meaning, or being sacred signs of fire and constellations, but mostly as a fertility symbol. In some areas, cup marks were and are used to sacrifice small coins, fat, small dolls or pins10. I went to a cup mark stone in the Northern Denmark—offering small coins.

Communication on the surface of the Earth

The Great Belt Bridge (Danish: Storebæltsbroen) can be seen from space by identifying the two pylons of the East Bridge. Inspired by crop circles and geoglyphsimagine, like A. Mercier11 and Carl Friedrich Gauss, mirrors on the pylons of The Great Belt Bridge, reflecting several laser beacons12, all together in combining petroglyphs.

 

NOTES

1. André Leroi-Gourhan, Gesture and Speech (Massachusetts: The MIT Press, 1993).
2. https://chat.openai.com/.
3. Thamis, “The Phoenician Alphabet & Language,” World History Encyclopedia, last mdoified January 18, 2012, https://www.worldhistory.org/article/17/the-phoenician-alphabet--language/.
4. Daniel Oberhaus, Extraterrestrial Languages (Massachusetts: The MIT Press, 2019).
5. “Alien Language,” dCode, accessed December 13, 2023, https://www.dcode.fr/alien-language.
6. Michael Auer, “The Strangest Ways We’ve Said Hello to the Universe,” Supercluster, June 10, 2019, https://www.supercluster.com/editorial/the-strangest-ways-we've-said-hello-to-the-universe.
7. Sabine Wedege, Communication with tones/frequencies, 2023, https://soundcloud.com/user-847678391/communication-with-tonesfrequencies.
8. “Skiltning til danske turistattraktioner,” Visitdanmark, last modified February 12 2008, https://web.archive.org/web/20080212131148/http:/www.visitdenmark.com/danmark/da-dk/menu/turist/oplevelser/attraktioner/sightseeing/skiltning+til+danske+turist+attraktioner.htm.
9. Jeffrey Vadala, An Introduction to Rock Art (New Haven: hraf.yale.edu, 2019); Johannes Lund Rasmussen, Okkerværket I Løvskal – et bidrag til dansk råstofudvindings historie (Copenhagen: Rigsarkivet, Erhvervshistorisk Årbog, 2018). In Løvskal, in the middle of Jutland between Viborg and Randers, there was an ochre works, active from 1916 to 1965. Today, only a few traces in the landscape are left, and there are only a few written sources of its history. This article paints a portrait of the history of the ochre works as a contribution to the history of Danish raw materials production. The ochre was mainly used by color factories, and the most well-known use was as an ingredient in the paint that gave the DSB's freight wagons its well-known reddish-brown color. Traditionally, ocher has been extracted from open quarries in the upper soil layers. Siena in Italy and Rousillon in France contain some of the largest commercially exploited deposits. In Denmark, ocher has been dug at the location Løvskal near Randers until the middle of the twentieth century. The most important deposits and sources have gained traction as named pigments in the painting tradition, e.g. Terra di Siena, Terra di Puozzola, Persian red and Løvskal ocher.
10. Søren Thrysøe, Skåltegnsten (Støvring: Støvring lokalhistoriske forenings medlemsblad ”Hanen”, 1982).
11. Florence Raulin Cerceau, “Les pionniers de la communication avec les autres planètes,” Pour la Science, last modified May 1, 2007.
12. Andres Picon, “Magnified laser from Earth could attract alien attention, MIT researcher says,” The Boston Globe, November 8, 2018, https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2018/11/08/magnified-laser-from-earth-could-attract-alien-attention-mit-researcher-says/HrbyazamrVaQ1NaBJhdllJ/story.html.

More Articles from &&&

Socialism after Socialism, A Response to Conrad Hamilton

In the spirit of dialogue, I am responding to the observations in Conrad Hamilton’s recent expansive review of my book The Political Theory of Liberal Socialism. I will be concentrating on Hamilton’s three main claims, that there is a gap between the form and content of socvialism, invoking Marxist theories of struggle before coming down… Read More »

Biennialese Blues: Review of Whitney Biennial 2026

ARTISTS: Basel Abbas & Ruanne Abou-Rahme, Kelly Akashi, Kamrooz Aram, Ash Arder, Teresa Baker, Sula Bermudez-Silverman, Zach Blas, Enzo Camacho & Ami Lien, Leo Castañeda, CFGNY, Nanibah Chacon, Maia Chao, Joshua Citarella, Mo Costello, Taína H. Cruz, Carmen de Monteflores, Ali Eyal, Andrea Fraser, Mariah Garnett, Ignacio Gatica, Jonathan González, Emilie Louise Gossiaux, Kainoa Gruspe,… Read More »

No View from Nowhere: On Discourse, Différance & Functorial Semantics of Micro-Communities

This essay argues that natural language semantics admits no global orientation—no ‘view from nowhere’—but only local positions within psychoanalytically and sociologically embedded discourse communities. Drawing on Derrida’s concept of différance, I demonstrate that meaning is constitutively deferred across the differential play of signs, precluding any meta-linguistic standpoint from which all local meanings could be adjudicated.… Read More »

Liberalism Is Dead, Long Live Liberalism!

Matthew McManus’ The Political Theory of Liberal Socialism is a powerful attempt to merge two disparate traditions, parlaying reformist compromise into a coherent political program. It also rests on the assumption that socialism is inherently illiberal, an assumption that deserves to be questioned. While often hailed as the single-minded son of America, perhaps the best… Read More »

Luxury Activism: Art, Fashion & Capital

[This text was previously published by the author in Portuguese on Contemporânea Magazine — Ed.] I don’t want to work with fashion. Beauty must be preserved from capitalism. Fashion favours the escape into personal, private, selected, chosen space, as a form of false self-determination. Fashion reflects the fear of losing’ identity. — Thomas Hirschhorn The purposelessness… Read More »

The Questions Concerning the Ethics of AI

With recent articles in &&& concerning the status of what is or is not Marxism, I took it upon myself to write a piece that I consider firmly placed in that tradition. I am not being paid by the CIA, I promise. Furthermore, despite appearances, my article is not an article in the “ethics of… Read More »

The Best Ever Art Basel Review that Qatar Money Can Buy

During the Art Basel Qatar’s VIP preview of Sweat Variant’s durational performance My Tongue is a Blade on February 4, two special seats up in front of the stage stayed empty for a while.  Empty with intent.  People hovered, looked, and reconsidered occupying them in their head at the last minute like they were about… Read More »

SUPPORT THE IRANIAN REVOLUTION 2026!

SIGN THE STATEMENT HERE The past several weeks have borne witness to a bloodbath in Iran amidst images of systematic massacre and horrific abuses of power by the Iranian government against its own people. As a united front, we stand together to uphold the following convictions: 1- That the Islamic Republic of Iran must come… Read More »

Rhetoric vs Reality: Iranian Regime Is an Imperialist Project Preventing a Free Palestine!

Since its founding, the Islamic Republic of Iran has cultivated legitimacy by embedding itself within global progressive movements—particularly those oriented around anti-imperialism and racial justice. Rhetoric, repeated, obscures reality: the Islamic Republic of Iran (IRI) is an imperialist project that will not enable a free Palestine. The IRI is built on an expansionist doctrine resembling… Read More »

On State Collapse & Democide in Iran

1. Middle Eastern Islamisms and Islamists are reorganizing in a post-jihadi/takfiri Muslim/Arab world within their national boundaries. First of all, the Taliban’s path back to Afghanistan was facilitated by the USA. Afghan Islamists were swift in adopting a more Afghanistan-focused vision and dismantling any public state capacity, especially in social and women’s affairs, built under… Read More »

How Was This Monster Born? Contemplations on the Ontology of the Iranian Islamic Republic

By Asal Mansouri and Borna Dehghani, writing from Tehran How can survival turn into something shameful? How does breathing itself become a burden – one that a person no longer dares to carry, a weight that grows heavier by the moment, with no path of escape left open? What took place across Iran in January… Read More »

The Human Centipede II: Qatar & the Broker’s Cut

If my first The Human Centipede: A View From the Art World (2013) traced the art world as a closed alimentary circuit, this sequel begins where that circuit was sublimated into brokerage as a state-form with unmistakable political aspirations.[1] The same logic is now in the open for everyone to witness, wearing the grimace of… Read More »

الغای زیر ساخت‌های شیعه اسلام در ایران 

ENGLISH VERSION در لحظه‌ای که این سطور نوشته می‌شود، ایران با زخمی باز زنده است. جامعهٔ ایران یکی از تاریک‌ترین مقاطع تاریخ معاصر خود را از سر می‌گذراند. ده‌ها هزار نفر در خیابان‌ها کشتار شده‌اند؛ معترضانِ زخمی توسط نیروهای امنیتی از بیمارستان‌ها ربوده می‌شوند؛ و اعدام‌ها در زندان‌ها به شکلی صنعتی ادامه دارد. خانواده‌ها آیین‌های… Read More »

Abolition of Infrastructural Shia Islam in Iran

FARSI VERSION As I write this, Iran is an open wound. Iranians are living through one of the darkest moments of their country’s contemporary history. Thousands upon thousands upon thousands have been massacred in the streets; wounded protesters are being removed from hospitals by security forces, and executions are taking place on an industrial scale… Read More »

ایران، بزرگترین دردسر: دربارهٔ سکوتِ مزمنِ بخشی از چپِ معاصر

با چیزی آغاز می‌کنم که در نگاه اول شبیه یک حاشیه‌روی است، یک خاطرهٔ قدیمیِ تلویزیونی که زمانی لبخند روی صورتِ ما می‌آورد. اما همین خاطره، مدلِ فشرده‌ای از یک واکنشِ سیاسی است که مدام در ایران تکرار می‌شود. وقتی جوان‌تر بودم، سریالی بود به نام «روزی روزگاری». یک پدیده شد و واقعاً هم عالی… Read More »

Regarding the Erasure of Iranian Uprising

The most recent state crackdown on Iranian protesters stands among the most violent suppressions of public dissent in Iran’s modern history. Protesters have been killed, blinded, and mass-arrested. As the state imposed a sweeping information blackout and advanced claims blaming foreign agents for the violence, this brutality has nonetheless been met with a striking absence… Read More »

Why Critical Theory Isn’t Marxism & Why Western Vs. Eastern Marxism is an Illusory Dichotomy?

I have almost finished Gabriel Rockhill’s “Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism?” (Monthly Review Press, 2025) amidst the uproar among the so-called progressive left academia and publishing. Rockhill has said the quiet truth out loud: the so-called critical theory has in fact nothing to do with Marxism. Its path has been paved by former… Read More »

Applied Collapse in Venezuela

The recent decapitation of the Venezuelan regime by the US military is part of a longer history of induced collapse: from Iraq to Afghanistan to Palestine, the techniques of empire have been wielded to destroy societies. But behind the Maduro extradition may be a kind of new American weakness.As you know, Nicolás Maduro and his… Read More »

Hard Habit to Break: On Political Readings of Art & Marxist Citationalism

I want to talk about a habit in contemporary art writing that I keep running into, especially in Marxist-inflected theory, where interpretation is substituted with citation and judgment is treated as an embarrassment. The pattern is familiar: the artwork becomes an occasion to rehearse a framework, the framework becomes a moral sorting machine, and the… Read More »

Computational Contemplation of
Burg of Babel

To watch a one-minute version of the film, please click here. Burg of Babel (2017-2024) is built on a very simple but unusual structure. On the screen, instead of one large moving image, the viewers see a grid made up of twenty-five rectangles, five across and five down, each playing the same 25-minute film, with… Read More »

Organized Callousness: Gaza & the Sociology of War*

Introduction The ongoing war in Gaza has generated extensive polemic among scholars and the general public.1 Some have described this conflict as a novel form of warfare. The deeply asymmetric character of this war and the vast number of Palestinian civilian casualties have prompted some analysts to described Gaza as a “new urban warfare.”2 Others… Read More »

Postcards from Mitteleuropa: Reviews from Sean Tatol’s European Tour*

Chris Sharp, Los Angeles slop-gallerist extraordinare, once scolded me on Instagram for comparing Raoul de Keyser to Peter Shear, evidently because he thinks it’s wrong to see connections between artists if they’re not from the same generation, which is a novel opinion if I’ve ever heard one. When I asked why that would be a… Read More »

Two Futures

In the brief essay that follows, I consider art as an event that de-privatizes the subject by exposing us to the hyperobjects constituted by the circulation of transgenerational trauma, power, and subjective identities. I also examine the role of contingency in this process and argue for art as a tool of indifferent future production. What… Read More »

9/11 & Televisual Intersubjectivity

The six-channel work I presented at Art In The Age Of…Asymmetrical Warfare exhibition reconstructs from video archives of the September 11th attacks the televisual unfolding of the event on CNN, Fox, NBC, CBS, ABC and BBC news networks. The synchronic and uninterrupted footage which is playing on a continuous loop starts with the networks’ mundane… Read More »

Exotopy, Neo-Orientalism and Postcolonial Curation

After visiting the Ordinary Moments exhibition, curated by Mansour Forouzesh and featuring a collective of Iranian independent photographers at the FUGA Gallery in Budapest, I was once again convinced that the consumption of modern Iranian visual culture in the West is essentially orientalistic. Precisely through the contrast this exhibition provides, one can see more clearly… Read More »